Carhartt Unisex Baby Knit Beanie Cuff Hat
$
4.8/5 (34266)
Classic gift for new baby arrivals.
Baby Shower Gift Ideas
Gifts for new babies and expecting parents.
Each idea below is matched to baby shower occasions in our catalog and ranked by how well it fits. Want something more specific? Use the gift finder to narrow by who it's for, their interests, and your budget.
Start a custom gift search → 
Pearhead First 5 Years Chevron Baby Memory Book with Clean-Touch Baby Safe Ink Pad to Make Baby's Hand or Footprint Included, Blue
$
4.8/5 (25277)
Classic gift for expecting parents.
Pearhead Baby Memory Book, First 5 Years Baby Milestone Book, Pregnancy Journal, Gender Neutral Newborn Keepsake, With Clean-Touch Ink Pad For Baby's Handprint or Footprint, Pink Chevron
$
4.8/5 (25277)
Classic gift for expecting parents and newborns.
Bedtime Originals Choo Choo Express Plush Elephant - Humphrey
$
4.8/5 (19370)
Sweet shower gift for a new baby.
Pearhead Hello Baby First 5 Years Memory Book, Gender-Neutral Baby Keepsake for New and Expectant Parents, Pregnancy And Milestone Journal, Modern Minimalist Black and Gold Polka Dot
$
4.8/5 (9894)
Classic gift for expecting parents.
Lucy Darling Baby Memory Book – Little Rainbow | First 5 Years Journal & Photo Album | Gender-Neutral Milestone Keepsake for Baby Boy or Girl | New Mom Gift
$$
4.8/5 (9334)
Ideal thoughtful gift for expecting parents.
First 5 Years Baby Memory Book Girl, Boy - 90 Pages Hardcover First Year Milestone Keepsake Book, Newborn Scrapbook for New Parents, Minimalist Photo Album Journal, New Mom Gifts (AdventureLand)
$
4.8/5 (7397)
Ideal for expecting parents starting a keepsake book.
Infantino Press & Stay Sensory Blocks, Developmental Activity Blocks, 24-Piece Multicolor Stacking Toy Set for Babies & Toddlers 12 Months+
$
4.4/5 (6983)
Strong newborn and toddler gift choice.
Keepsake Memory Book for Baby Boy or Girl Timeless First 5 Year Baby Book A Milestone Book to Record Every Event from Birth to Age 5 Gender Neutral Journal Scrapbook Photo Album
4.9/5 (6779)
Classic gift for expecting parents.
Baby Hand and Footprint Kit - Quick Dry Clay Baby Footprint Kit, Pets Paw, Newborn Keepsake Picture Frame for Boys, Girls, Personalized New Mom Gifts for Shower & Registry, Grandparents (Alpine White)
$
4.6/5 (6680)
Classic gift for expecting parents and registries.
Mary Meyer Putty Nursery Soft Toy, Hound, 1 Count (Pack of 1)
$
4.8/5 (6152)
Great newborn gift for expecting families.
Pearhead Baby Hand and Footprint Kit - Inkless No Mess Clean-Touch Ink Pad, Newborn Keepsake Frame, Nursery Decor Essentials, Perfect Shower Gift for Boys and Girls, White
$
4.7/5 (6043)
Classic gift for expecting parents
Pearhead Baby Hand & Footprint Keepsake Frame with Inkless Clean-Touch Pad, Newborn Handprint Footprint Kit, Gender-Neutral Nursery Décor, Baby Registry & Shower Gift, Beige Mat
$
4.7/5 (6043)
Made for baby registry gifting.
KeaBabies Baby Hand and Footprint Kit - Clay Handprint Keepsake Frame, Newborn Nursery Picture Frame, Personalized New Mom Gifts for Baby First Christmas Shower (Alpine White)
$
4.7/5 (6011)
Classic gift for expecting parents
KeaBabies Baby Hand and Footprint Kit - Clay Handprint Keepsake Frame, Newborn Nursery Picture Frame, Personalized New Mom Gifts for Baby First Christmas Shower (Ash Wood)
$
4.7/5 (6011)
Classic gift for expecting parents.
KeaBabies Baby Hand and Footprint Kit - Clay Handprint Keepsake Frame, Newborn Nursery Picture Frame, Personalized New Mom Gifts for Baby First Christmas Shower (Auburn)
$
4.7/5 (6004)
Classic gift for expecting families
Baby Handprint Footprint Keepsake Ornament Kit (Makes 2) - Bonus Stencil for Personalized Christmas, Newborn, New Mom & Shower Gifts. 2 Easels! Non-Toxic Clay, Air-Dries Light & Soft, Won't Crack.
$
4.2/5 (5072)
Strong fit for expecting parents and showers.
Kids Preferred Disney Baby Winnie the Pooh and Friends Stuffed Animal with Jingle and Crinkle, Pooh 12”
$
4.8/5 (4974)
Great for new babies and expecting parents.
Peachly Baby Memory Book | Baby Book First Year Baby Book Keepsake for Milestones | Simple Cute Baby Scrapbook | Baby Books for Girl | Natural Linen - Clementine
$$
4.8/5 (4475)
Classic gift for expecting parents.
Peachly Unisex Baby Memory Book | Minimalist Baby First Year Keepsake for Milestones | Baby Books First Year Memory Book | Simple Baby Scrapbook for Boy Girl Milestones | Natural Linen - Olive
$$
4.8/5 (4475)
Perfect for celebrating a new baby's arrival.
Pioneer Photo Albums DA-200COLB/B 200-Pocket Embossed Baby Leatherette Frame Cover Album for 4 by 6-Inch Prints, Blue
$
4.8/5 (4462)
Ideal for expecting parents and newborn memories
Baby Hand and Footprint Kit Girls, Boys - Personalized Baby’s First Christmas Ornament Kit, Newborn Gifts for New Mom, Cute Shower Gifts for Mother's Day,Easy to Use Handprint Ornaments(Gold Paint)
$
4.4/5 (4157)
Fits baby shower and new baby gifting.
Aurora® Snuggly Loppy Giraffe™ Baby Stuffed Animal - Comforting Companion - Imaginative Play - Brown 8 Inches
$
4.8/5 (4023)
Classic baby shower plush gift.
Little Hippo Baby Ornament Keepsake Kit (Newborn Bundle) - 2 Easels, 4 Ribbons & Letters! Handprint and Footprint Clay Casting Kit for Baby Shower Gifts, Boys & Girls
$
4.4/5 (3723)
Direct fit for expecting parent gifts.
Questions about baby shower gifts
What are good baby shower gifts?
Good baby shower gifts balance the recipient's interests with a price that feels right for your relationship. Buyyyah ranks baby shower ideas by fit — the picks above are a curated starting point, and the gift finder can tailor them to the exact person and budget.
How does Buyyyah choose these baby shower gifts?
Every product is scored against baby shower occasions using relevance weights, then ranked. Buyyyah is a discovery tool, not a store: links go to Amazon and commissions never change the ranking.